skip navigation

Situation 6 Charts

One player assessed a double minor or a major plus a minor penalty.

TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2+2 No one returns
4:30 Goal

The first minor penalty to X terminates. His second minor penalty begins at 4:30. Double minor penalties are treated as two separate penalties.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2+2 X Returns
5:30 Goal

X’s first minor penalty has expired so the second penalty terminates.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 5+2 No one returns
4:30 Goal

The major penalty must be served first.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 5+2 X Returns
8:30 Goal

The major penalty has expired so the minor penalty terminates.


Two players on the same team assessed combinations of minor and major penalties.

TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2 X Returns
4:00 Y-2
4:45 Goal

The minor penalty to X had less time remaining than Y’s


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2 X Returns
4:00 Y-5
4:45 Goal

The only minor penalty being served is X's.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-5 Y Returns
4:00 Y-2
4:45 Goal

The only minor penalty being served is Y's.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2+2 No one returns
4:00 Y-2
4:45 Goal

The first minor penalty to X terminates. It has less time remaining than Y's.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2+2 Y Returns
4:00 Y-2
5:30 Goal

The second penalty to X began at 5:00. The minor penalty to Y began before the second penalty to X. Double minor penalties are always treated as two separate minor penalties.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 5+2 Y Returns
4:00 Y-2
4:45 Goal

X must serve his major penalty first. A major penalty cannot terminate as the result of a goal scored.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 5+2 Y Returns
7:30 Y- 2
8:05 Goal

The minor penalty to X began at 8:00. The minor penalty to Y terminates as this penalty had the lesser time remaining.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
4:00 X- 5+2 Both X and Y Return
7:00 Y- 2
9:00 Goal

The minor penalty to Y and the major penalty to X have expired. The minor penalty to X terminates as a result of the goal.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:40 X- 5+2 Captain’s choice of X or Y return
8:40 Y- 2
9:10 Goal

The major penalty has already expired. The minor penalties to X and Y are scheduled to expire at the same time.


Three players on the same team assessed a combination of minor and major penalties. “Sig.” = the infraction is being signaled by the Referee when the goal is scored.

TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2 X returns; Team A remains short- handed by 2 players
3:30 Y- 2
4:00 Z- 2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X had less time remaining than Y’s. The delayed penalty to Z starts at 4:30.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2 X and Y return; Team A will be short-handed by one player
3:30 Y- 2
4:00 Z- 2
5:15 Goal

The penalty to X expired, and the minor penalty to Y had less time remaining than Z’s. The delayed penalty to Z began at 5:00, upon the expiration of the penalty to X.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 X returns and the signaled penalty to Z is assessed; Team A remains short handed by 2 players.
3:30 Y-2
Sig. Z-2
4:30 Goal

The penalty to X had less time remaining than Y’s. Only one minor penalty can be terminated as the result of a goal scored.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 Y returns and the signaled penalty to Z is assessed; (X returned at 5:00); Team A will be short handed by one player.
3:30 Y-2
Sig. Z-2
5:15 Goal

The penalty to Y was the only minor penalty being served at the time of the goal.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-5 Y returns and the signaled penalty to Z is assessed; Team A remains shorthanded by 2 players.
3:30 Y-2
Sig. Z-2
4:30 Goal

A major penalty cannot terminate as the result of a goal scored. The penalty to Y was the only minor penalty being served at the time of the goal.


One player on each team assessed a combination of minor and major penalties.

TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2 No one returns
3:30 B- 2
4:15 Goal

The teams were at equal numerical strength at the time of the goal, so no penalty may be terminated.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2+2 No one returns
3:30 B- 2
4:15 Goal

The teams were at equal numerical strength at the time of the goal, so no penalty may be terminated.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-5+2 No one returns
3:30 B- 2
4:15 Goal

The teams were at equal numerical strength at the time of the goal, so no penalty may be terminated.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-5+2 No one returns
8:30 B- 2
9:40 Goal

The major penalty to X has expired, but the teams were still at equal numerical strength at the time of the goal.


Unequal number of players assessed a combination of minor and major penalties.

TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2 X Returns
3:30 B- 2
4:00 Y-2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X had less time remaining than the minor to Y.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2 X returns
3:30 Y-2
4:00 B- 2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X had less time remaining than the minor to Y.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 B- 2 X Returns
3:30 X-2
4:00 Y-2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X had less time remaining than the minor to Y.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 B-2 X Returns
3:30 X-2
4:00 Y-5
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X is the only Team A penalty eligible for termination.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 X Returns
3:30 B-5
4:00 Y-2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X had less time remaining than the minor to Y.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 X Returns
3:30 B-2
4:00 Y-5
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X is the only Team A penalty eligible for termination.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 X Returns
3:30 B-5
4:00 Y-5
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X is the only Team A penalty eligible for termination.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-5 Y Returns
3:30 Y-2
4:00 B-2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to Y is the only Team A penalty eligible for termination.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-5 Y Returns
3:30 B-2
4:00 Y-2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to Y is the only Team A penalty eligible for termination.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 X Returns
3:30 Y-5
4:00 B-2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X is the only Team A penalty eligible for termination.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 B-5 X Returns
3:30 X-2
4:00 Y-2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X had less time remaining than the minor to Y.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2+2 First minor penalty to X terminates.
3:30 B-2
4:00 Y-2
4:30 Goal

The first minor penalty to X had less time remaining than Y’s. On-ice numerical strength remains unchanged when play resumes.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 X returns; Team A is still serving two penalties.
3:15 Y-2
3:30 B-2
3:35 Z-2
4:00 Goal

The minor penalty to X had less time remaining than Y's. The delayed minor penalty to Z begins at 4:00.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 X and Y Return
3:15 Y-2
3:30 B-2
3:35 Z-2
5:10 Goal

The penalty to X has expired at 5:00. The minor penalty to Y had less time remaining than Z's (which began at 5:00).


An equal number of opposing players are assessed penalties at the same time.

TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-5+2 B- 2+2 No one returns
4:30 Goal

Both teams were at equal numerical strength at the time of the goal. The minor penalty to X and one of the minors to B offset, thus Team A will play short handed 5 minutes and Team B for 2 minutes.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-5+2 B-5 The player serving the minor for X returns.
4:30 Goal

The coincident major penalties were offset, thus the minor penalty started immediately.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 X Returns
3:30 Y-2 B-2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X is the only penalty being displayed on the penalty clocks.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 B-2 Y Returns
3:30 Y-2
4:30 Goal

At 3:00 both teams remained at full numerical strength because the coincident minor penalties to X and B are offset. Y’s minor penalty is the only penalty eligible for termination.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 B-2 No One Returns
3:30 Y-5
4:00 Goal

At 3:00 both teams remained at full numerical strength because the coincident minor penalties to X and B are offset. A major penalty cannot expire as the result of a goal.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 B-5 X Returns
3:30 Y-2
4:00 Goal

Each team received one penalty at the same time (3:00), but those minor and major penalties are not considered as “coincident.” The minor penalty to X had less time remaining than Y’s.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 B-5 X Returns
3:30 Y-5
4:30 Goal

As in the previous example, the two penalties at 3:00 are not considered as “coincident.” The minor penalty to X is the only penalty eligible for termination.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 X Returns
3:30 Y-5 B-5
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X is the only penalty eligible for termination. The major penalties are coincident and are offset.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-5 No One Returns
3:30 Y-2 B-2
4:30 Goal

The coincident minor penalties to Y and B offset. A major penalty cannot terminate as the result of a goal scored.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-5 Y Returns
3:30 Y-2 B-5
4:30 Goal

As explained previously, the penalties at 3:30 are not considered “coincident.” The minor penalty to Y is the only penalty eligible for termination.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2+2 B-2 The player serving the minor for X returns.
3:30 Y-2 B-5
4:30 Goal

The first minor penalty to X and the minor penalty to B are coincident. The second minor penalty to X began at 3:00, and had less time remaining than Y’s minor penalty. X must remain on the penalty bench until the first stoppage at or after 6:30.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X- 2+2 B-5 The first minor penalty to X expires Goal (the team remains short-handed)
3:30 Y-2
4:30 Goal

As explained previously, penalties at 3:00 are not considered “coincident.” The first minor penalty to X had less time remaining than Y’s minor.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 B-2 Z Returns
3:30 Y-5
4:00 Z-2
4:30 Goal

At 3:00 both teams remained at full numerical strength. The coincident minor penalties to X and B are offset. The minor penalty to Z is the only penalty eligible for termination.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 X Returns
3:30 Y-5 B-2
4:30 Goal

Team A is short-handed, and the minor penalty to X is the only penalty eligible for termination.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 X Returns
3:30 Y-5 B-2
4:00 Z-2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalty to X is the only penalty eligible for termination. The delayed penalty to Z begins at 4:30.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 B-2 Captain’s choice of X or Y’s penalty to terminate
Y-2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalties to X and Y are scheduled to expire at the same time. The coincident minor penalties to B and either X or Y (Captain’s choice at the time the penalties are assessed) are offset.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 B-2 No One Returns
Y-5
4:30 Goal

Team A is short-handed by reason of a major penalty. A major penalty cannot terminate as the result of a goal scored. The coincident minor penalties to X and B are offset.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 B-5 Captain's choice of X or Y's penalty to terminate.
Y-2
4:30 Goal

The minor penalties to X and Y are scheduled to expire at the same time.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 B-5 X Returns
Y-5
4:30 Goal

Immediate substitution for B and Y are permitted because coincident major penalties are offset.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2+2 B-2 Captain’s choice (made when assessed).
Y-2 • If Y was coincident, X’s first minor ends.
4:30 Goal • X’s first minor was coincident, either X’s or Y’s penalty ends.

The first penalty to X and the penalty to Y are scheduled to expire at the same time. The coincident minor penalties to B and either the first penalty to X or the penalty to Y (Captain’s choice at the time the penalties are assessed) are offset. Team A choice to be one player shorthanded for 4 minutes or two players shorthanded for 2 minutes.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-2 B-2 Captain’s choice of X, Y or Z’s penalty to terminate
Y-2
Z-2 Goal
4:30

At 3:00, the Captain has to make a choice of which coincident minor penalty would be offset with the penalty to B. Upon the goal being scored, it is the Captain’s choice of which of the remaining two penalties will expire.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B ANSWER
3:00 X-5 B-2 Captain’s choice of Y or Z’s penalty to terminate
Y-2
Z-2
4:30 Goal

At 3:00, the Captain has to make a choice of which coincident minor penalty would be offset with the penalty to B.


Note to situation referenced above: Because of the coincident penalties, Team A had the choice to be one player short-handed for 4 minutes or two players short-handed for 2 minutes. Effects of this choice based on a goal against at 4:30 when play resumes:

One player short-handed for 4 minutes: Remaining penalty time is 2:00 for Player X. Two players short-handed for 2 minutes: Remaining penalty time is 0:30 for the “non-coincident” Player.

Specific examples that illustrate how the coincident minor penalty rule is to be applied.

TIME TEAM A TEAM B
#10 #21 #3 #6
5:10 2 min 3 min

Immediate substitution for #10 and #3. Both teams play at full on-ice strength.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B
#10 #21 #3 #6
5:10 2 min 2 min
2 min 2 min

Immediate substitution for #10 and #3. Both teams play at full on-ice strength.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B
#10 #21 #3 #6
5:10 2min 2 min 2 min 2 min

Immediate substitution for #10, #21, #3 and #6. Both teams play at full on-ice strength.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B
#10 #21 #3 #6
5:10 2 min 2 min 2 min
2 min

Immediate substitution for #10 , #21 and #3. Both teams play at full on-ice strength.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B
#10 #21 #3 #6
5:10 2 min 2 min
2 min

Immediate substitution for #10. Substitution for #3 after 2 minutes. An additional player shall be immediately placed on the penalty bench to “serve” the first minor penalty to #3.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B
#10 #21 #3 #6
5:10 2 min 5 min
2 min

Immediate substitution for #10. Substitution for #3 after 5 minutes. An additional player shall be immediately placed on the penalty bench to “serve” the major penalty to #3.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B
#10 #21 #3 #6
5:10 5 min 2 min
2 min

No substitution. All penalties are served by the penalized players. They return upon expiration.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B
#10 #21 #3 #6
5:10 2 min 2 min 2 min

Immediate substitution for #10. Captain’s choice of immediate substitution for #3 or #6. Team B will play short-handed for 2 minutes.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B
#10 #21 #3 #6
5:10 2 min 2 min 2 min 2 min
2 min

Immediate substitution for #10, #21, and #3. Team B will play short-handed for 2 minutes.


TIME TEAM A TEAM B
#10 #21 #3 #6
5:10 2 min 2 min 2 min
2 min

Immediate substitution for #10. Captain’s choice of a.) immediate substitution for #6 (team plays short-handed by one player for 4 minutes), OR b.) offsetting the first minor penalty to #3, placing an additional player on the penalty bench to “serve” the minor penalty to #3 and skating short-handed by two players for 2 minutes.


Always offset an equal number of minor penalties, regardless of the number of players receiving those penalties. Equal time penalties to an equal number of players is not a requirement in the application of the Coincident Minor Penalty rule.


Here are a couple of hints to grasp the penalty termination concept:

Take note of the first minor penalty time which properly goes onto the penalty clock. As long as that penalty is being served, it terminates if that team is scored upon and they are below the on-ice numerical strength of the scoring team. The order of subsequent penalties doesn’t matter.

Make sure your Penalty Timekeeper doesn’t put coincident minors on the penalty clocks. This will really complicate your decision-making, and selling your call, if times show on the clock and both teams are still skating at full strength.